A woman turned to the Reddit community for support after learning her boyfriend was not the biological father of the little girl she had helped care for.

She explained that she and her boyfriend had been together for two and a half years and that his ex, whom she called Ashley, had always been a source of strain.

“She was verbally, physically, & financially abusive,” the poster wrote in her post, adding that her boyfriend had been in therapy and “made great progress” since they began dating.

The woman shared that she didn’t meet his daughter until nearly a year into the relationship, and from the start, she and Ashley never got along. “She is extremely manipulative and has continued to exploit my bf the entirety of our relationship,” she explained, saying that whenever she pointed it out, he insisted he was “being the bigger person for his child.”

Despite the tension, the little girl grew close to her, and for a time she tried to support both father and daughter.

Over the years, the ongoing conflict with Ashley caused her to set boundaries for herself. “I no longer do pick ups or drop offs with her and I no longer babysit on her court ordered days,” she wrote, noting that Ashley rarely took her daughter overnight and only when convenient. Her boyfriend understood and supported these limits, but the resentment lingered as she watched him continue to accommodate his ex.

Things changed dramatically when her boyfriend was required to take a paternity test to enroll his daughter in a program. The test revealed he was not the girl’s biological father, a discovery the woman described as shocking. “I was shocked as they look so much alike,” she wrote, adding that she tried to give him “space and time to accept and grieve this information” before discussing next steps.

Eventually, she sat down with him to talk through what needed to happen legally, even though she knew it would be painful. “I told him he will need to get legal counsel and inform the biological father if she knows who he is,” she wrote.

But he reacted emotionally, telling her she was being cold. “He called me heartless and said they might take her away,” she shared, clarifying that she wasn’t trying to hurt him but believed he needed to “prepare for” the possibility.

Over the following week, her own feelings began to shift in ways she didn’t expect. She realized she no longer wanted to raise the child, even though she knew her boyfriend would continue to do so without hesitation.

“My feelings of resentment stem from Ashley never having to deal with the consequences of her actions,” she wrote, adding that she couldn’t separate the situation from “my hatred for her mistreatment of my bf.”

Her boyfriend, she said, was “an amazing father,” and she knew he would continue loving and caring for the little girl as if she were his own. But for her, remaining in the situation felt emotionally impossible.

“It’s something I don’t want to watch up close,” she explained, admitting that she had moved in with her sister while she sorted through her emotions. “I just cannot get past the destruction and hurt that woman has caused,” she wrote, acknowledging that her decision wasn’t “fair to my bf or his daughter” but that she knew her limits.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Commenters were largely empathetic to the difficult crossroads she faced. One wrote, “You don’t want the family he is offering. You gave it a go but the juice wasn’t worth the squeeze,” adding that ending the relationship was likely better for both of them in the long run.

Another commenter sympathized with how much Ashley had contributed to the emotional turmoil, saying, “I think it is more having to deal with Ashley the rest of your life. Which makes sense.”

After sharing her story, she emphasized how painful it was to admit the truth out loud. “This was not an easy decision,” she wrote, “but I feel it’s necessary for my mental health.”